Why Don’t We Just Scrap The Police Altogether?

Last Updated on September 26, 2015 by RetiredAndAngry

Not my idea I must point out, but it really is quite amazing the ideas that our academics and Think Tanks can come up with.

However, I was settled on my sofa, getting comfy waiting for the game with an odd-shaped ball to begin when the phone rang, it was Bronwen again. My word she’s been busy lately.  Apparently she’d overheard a group of academics nattering after a conference.

One of them was whispering that Steve White, chair of the Police Federation for England and Wales, had pointed out that 84 per cent of calls to the police relate to ‘non-crime incidents’. In an article appearing in The Guardian on 7 September Richard Garside, suggests that slashing police budgets provides us with the opportunity to rebalance public policy and roll back police mission creep into almost all areas of public service.

Does this mean what I think it means?  Radically downsize the Police Service, and by doing so, force other public Sector Services to take responsibility for their own areas of concern?

We all know that downsizing the police has been an issue of concern for certain Think Tanks for some time. Last year Professor Tim Hope wrote an article about abolishing the police service altogether. He proposes that we should establish a civil harm-response unit in its place, formed through the merger of police, fire and ambulance services.  Sounds very similar to something that a certain. PCC is proposing.

To quote the good professor, and I sincerely hope that I’m not infringing anybody’s copyright here

To serve the public good, the uniformed police service should merge thoroughly with the community health, ambulance and fire services to become a harm-response service with the delegated task of protecting and offering succour to the victims of crime. Alongside the other public services, the police should promote community safety as a means of promoting public health based upon a genuine public commitment to the well-being of the community, in all its many varied and diverse ways of life. Nor when its services are not required should it intrude upon the privacy and liberty of citizens.

To fulfil their role as a public service, a level of education and training is needed for entry into a profession that can stand alongside other public servants such as nurses, teachers and social workers instead of the in-service indoctrination of impressionable recruits lacking in either higher education or life-experience.

As for the many investigative and regulatory functions performed by the state, including law enforcement, appropriate agencies need to be formed and staffed by their own investigatory officials, with as much, or as little, powers of investigation and arrest as their statutory foundations allow them. Since much of this activity now takes place or is known about in cyberspace, regulatory and policing functions need to be focussed appropriately and competently by suitable agencies, rather than seen as simply another task to be grabbed by a squad of hastily trained police officers.

Finally, the maintenance of public order and safety should also fall within the capability of a civil harm-response service. Those political liberties upon which the police were founded did not sanction paramilitary force, nor do we need it now.

So I really must thank Bronwen for bringing these two shining examples of academia to my attention.  Where would we be without Think Tanks and Acacemics?  No rude answers please.

7 comments on “Why Don’t We Just Scrap The Police Altogether?

  1. Alan I could say it would never happen, but after years of dismissing so many crackpot Schemes say “that’s ridiculous, it will never work surely they’d never implement that” only to see yet another crackpot Scheme implemented and fail. No matter how many times you think “told you so” and “perhaps they’ll know better in future”
    They never learn and yet another “LOB” will be introduced to the detriment of the tax paying public.
    So this stuff is worrying!
    Hell if they continue as they are there won’t be enough Police to do the job so getting rid of the Police will be an easy step!

    • I did read it and I shared it on Facebook and Twitter. I thought it was honest and balanced and reached the same conclusion as many of us. No wonder the government ignores his work.

  2. Perhaps the learned professors/think tankers would be part of the community response team that goes to the schizophrenic axe man that has gone ape and decided to have his local MP for tea, literally, or your common or garden drug dealer who took offence at his runner not giving him his drug money and issued a formal warning, with a claw hammer, a weekly occurrence down my way btw. I’d be happy for them to take my place, bring it on.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *